Audi A5 Forum & Audi S5 Forum banner

clutch failiure

2.3K views 11 replies 5 participants last post by  sayek  
#1 · (Edited)
Hi everyone I'm Phil and I'm new to the forum, and new to Audi ownership.

Last week I bought an A5 3.0tdi with 180k miles on the clock. I've known the car for 4 years as it was my boss's car, and it's always been utterly reliable, and it drove faultlessly.

On the 6th day of my ownership, the clutch suddenly failed. one minute it worked fine, the next it just didn't work at all. on previous cars I've had the clutch has failed more gradually with the biting point getting higher, but I'm not sure if any of my previous cars had hydraulic clutches, which could account for that (I know basically nothing about that but it seems like a possibility).

so, I have a couple of questions for you knowledgable folks to answer for me please:

Is there chance it's a master cylinder problem, or some other issue that doesn't involve dropping the gearbox? brake fluid is still full and I've tried pumping the clutch pedal and crossing my fingers

how much should I expect to spend on getting a new clutch and DMF fitted by an indy VAG specialist? I'm in Newark, Notts UK. theres a VAG specialist here but they haven't got back to me with a price yet

is it worth replacing the DMF if its within tolerance?

are LUK clutch parts any good, or should I go with Audi parts? cost is a huge factor for me as I have basically no money after buying the car, so I have no problem with 3rd party bits if they get the job done and last a long time.

I think that's everything but any advice would be hugely appreciated. for reference the car is a 2008 coupe

thank you
 
#6 ·
ok I've been quoted £1180 for a clutch and flywheel from a local independent German car specialist (JMC in Suttom in Ashfield), which I'm happy with as I was expecting the thick end of 2 grand. Parts were £460 and the rest is labour, so I'm bringing it in tomorrow. the mechanic I spoke to said they've done lots of them on my exact model, and it takes about 6 and a half hours as the sub frame needs removing, gearbox needs dropping ect. I'd like to add quotes from other places, but if the other 4 garages I asked for quotes 3 didn't get back to me and one refused to do it as he's "too old to be messing about with clutches" lol. I'm looking forward to getting my car back on the road, as I've loved every minute of driving it, up until the clutch failed
 
#7 ·
Mate your price sounds good to me, you were just unlucky that the clutch gave no symptoms at all before it gave up the ghost. BUT at that mileage I think that it is fair. Photos of the car please!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: b33evs
#9 ·
as luck would have it my phone broke about the same time as the clutch, so I'll take a photo when I get the car back. it really wasn't my week haha. driving it to the garage with no clutch today it had a bit of a shudder and slipped a bit on acceleration so I'm fairly sure it's completely gone. there was also a brake fluid warning on the dash even though the reservoir was full, so I guess that must be the slave cylinder on it's way out too
 
#8 ·
Its just bad luck you buy the car and a huge repair bill.
The price of the parts sound ok. The fitting cost will vary depending on if the garage add VAT or cash in hand really.

If I was buying a car with that kind of mileage I would expect the clutch/DMF on borrowed time if original.
 
#10 ·
just my luck - last time I bought a fairly decent car it was a Shogun that also lasted exactly 6 days before the fuel pump went. that one went to the scrap man unfortunately. price seemed decent to me and its inc vat for a full LUK kit including slave cylinder so I'm happy with that. the car only cost £500 so although I could have done without the expense it's still a steal!
 
#11 ·
Mate you win some and you lose some but it sounds like you are still ahead......